Thursday, December 16, 2010

VA Judge Makes Elementary Error In Health Care Ruling

TPM reports Amateur Hour: VA Judge Makes Elementary Error In Health Care Ruling. "The Virginia federal district court judge who ruled yesterday that the individual mandate in the health care bill is unconstitutional is catching a lot of flack -- and not just for having a financial interest in an anti-health care reform consulting firm.

Legal experts are attacking Judge Henry Hudson's decision on the merits, citing an elementary logical flaw at the heart of his opinion. And that has conservative scholars -- even ones sympathetic to the idea that the mandate is unconstitutional -- prepared to see Hudson's decision thrown out."

No comments: